MuskogeePhoenix.com, Muskogee, OK

Editorials

Discussion

August 19, 2012

Panhandling ordinance off base

— Muskogee’s new panhandling ordinance appears to target those that make us uncomfortable instead of addressing any issue of poverty.

The ordinance would prevent “aggressive” tactics used by some panhandlers soliciting money, food, work or other things.

The ordinance bans anyone from approaching, speaking to, or following a person “before, during or after panhandling” if the conduct would instill a sense of fear or intimidation.

The ordinance seems aimed at a segment of our population that some would rather quietly outlaw than help.

Councilor Randy Howard says panhandling poses a risk to public safety.

Maybe.

But there are plenty of laws on the books to punish violent crimes.

Howard also is concerned how begging might tarnish the way others view our city.

Trying to legislate beggars from the streets of Muskogee won’t help our image much.

Plus, begging is constitutionally protected speech. Government can’t keep beggars from begging.

Councilors also were concerned with panhandlers scamming citizens.

That’s true, too.

Not every beggar has a real issue that requires your financial help.

Some want you to provide the cash needed to support their drug, alcohol or gambling addictions.

There always will be some risk when it comes to compassion. Trying to help those truly in need will sometimes mean helping those who do not do enough to help themselves.

If you spend your life trying to help those less fortunate, you will be scammed some day.

It is the price of doing business as a compassionate person.

Text Only
Editorials